Dardanelle Missionary Baptist Church — Dardanelle, Arkansas
Pastor Chuck Trusty — Sunday evening service, October 11, 2026 1-2-3 John · Unit 2 · 1 John 1:5-10
► Watch this lesson on video (40:58)

Three Lies and the Truth
This is the lesson the way it was preached on Sunday evening - near word for word. The “uh”s and the starts-over are taken out; the sentences are left the way they were said. Bible verses are printed exactly as they read in the King James. Anything marked GOING DEEPER was NOT preached on Sunday evening - it is extra study for anyone who wants to dig further.
Well, it is good to have the opportunity to be here again this evening. This is the second lesson on First John - and you remember a couple of weeks ago we talked about the Apostle John and how he was an eyewitness there in Ephesus. He kept talking about how he had literally SEEN Jesus with his eyes and touched Him with his hands. And we learned why John wrote this first letter: its purpose was so that those who read it would have the same kind of fellowship with God, with Jesus, and with one another that the Apostle John had with God, with Jesus, and with his fellow worshippers . . . and also so that our joy in Christ might be FULL.
We talked about fellowship - and when we hear that word we think, “Oh, we are going to go drink a cup of coffee, we are going to go eat a meal.” Well, in the days in which this was written, the word actually referred to PARTNERS who own something together. The example we used was this: it is supper time, and I am acquainted with the family, I am acquainted with the cook . . . and the door is cracked open and they stick me a plate out through the crack in the door, and I sit out in the yard to eat. As opposed to - they open the door and invite me in, and I sit down at the table with the rest of the family. Now that is two types of fellowship, and one is quite a bit closer than the other. And that is the idea here, people . . . we can be a saved, born-again child of God, just as saved as the Apostle Paul, and have a DISTANT kind of relationship with the God who saved our souls - or we can have a very close fellowship with the God who saved our souls.
The Message John Heard
This evening we are going to begin with chapter one and verse five, and notice that verse five mentions “the message.” Now he is talking about the message that he is reporting.
“This then is the message which we have heard of him, and declare unto you, that God is light, and in him is no darkness at all.” - 1 John 1:5 (KJV)
So John is telling us that the message he is putting down in this letter is not something he sat down and thought of, and it is not the result of his studies over several different years. The message he is giving is something he HEARD - these ears heard it directly from the mouth of Jesus Christ. This is coming directly from God.
Now “God is light, and in him is no darkness at all” - well, what exactly is that supposed to mean? If Jesus is light, then, “Preacher, what about people like me that have a lot of shadows, to put it politely? What about people like me who possess a lot of darkness in my life? If God is light, what kind of shape does that put me in? Does that mean I am lost? Does that mean I have to keep doing something in order to drive the shadows away so that I will not become lost?”
Well, we are going to read all of these verses - one John one, five through ten.
“This then is the message which we have heard of him, and declare unto you, that God is light, and in him is no darkness at all. If we say that we have fellowship with him, and walk in darkness, we lie, and do not the truth: But if we walk in the light, as he is in the light, we have fellowship one with another, and the blood of Jesus Christ his Son cleanseth us from all sin. If we say that we have no sin, we deceive ourselves, and the truth is not in us. If we confess our sins, he is faithful and just to forgive us our sins, and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness. If we say that we have not sinned, we make him a liar, and his word is not in us.” - 1 John 1:5-10 (KJV)
Notice here there is an “if we say . . . if we say . . . if we say” - and an “if we confess.” Now the one point of our lesson this evening is this:
GOING DEEPER · THREE LIES AND TWO TRUTHS
Not preached on Sunday evening - extra study.
Look at how these verses are built. Verse six is a lie . . . and verse seven is the truth. Verse eight is a lie . . . and verse nine is the truth. And verse ten is a lie - and then the chapter stops. That is three lies and two truths, and John answers the third lie in chapter two.
God is not asking for a perfect record - God is asking for an honest walk.
God is asking that we avoid these three lies, and not say these untrue things in an effort to build ourselves up in our own eyes and in the eyes of others.
In God Is No Darkness at All
Now we are told here that in God there is no darkness AT ALL. This is significant in the language this was written in: John uses “no” twice - he doubles it. John doubles the “no” he uses in this verse, and I will tell you what that means in just a second. According to the source I looked at, John used the strongest way possible for the language to say NONE. There is no darkness in Jesus Christ or in God at all. And if we go to James one and seventeen, we read where there is no variableness, neither shadow of turning.
“Every good gift and every perfect gift is from above, and cometh down from the Father of lights, with whom is no variableness, neither shadow of turning.” - James 1:17 (KJV)
Now the significance of this - think about the difference between light and darkness. Light shows what is actually THERE. If God is light, doesn’t God’s word show us what we really are? You see the connection there. Light shows us what is actually there. A lot of times, especially with kids in the house, we play pretend a lot - that is just something Grandpa and the kids do. But when you turn the light on and everything in the room is clearly exposed, you cannot pretend anymore. You cannot pretend there is a boogeyman over here in the corner when the light is on. “Grandpa, there is no boogeyman in the corner - I can see.” So light takes the pretense completely away.
Darkness, on the other hand, is the opposite of light - and it does the opposite THING that light does. Light exposes . . . darkness hides. It is easy to pretend something that is not true in a place of darkness. So walking with God - notice the way this scripture words it: “If we say we have fellowship with him and walk in darkness, we lie. But if we walk in the light as he is in the light, we have fellowship one with another.” So walking means that if we follow God’s will, if we allow God’s word to expose what we really are, then we are walking out in the open . . . we are walking where there is no place to hide. If we are not walking with God, then we are walking in the shadows - we are walking in darkness.
GOING DEEPER · WHEN THE POWER GOES OUT
Not preached on Sunday evening - extra study.
For you little ones - when the power goes out at night and the house goes black, the first thing Mama does is find the flashlight. And when that flashlight comes on, whatever is on the floor shows up - the toys, the shoes, the dog. Well, God is a light that never goes off, and nothing in God’s house stays hidden.
Now why would we choose to walk in the darkness instead of in the light? There is a scripture - I think it is John chapter three, you can correct me - that says they avoid the light because their deeds are evil. I am not quite sure where that is. Is that John third chapter or not? I do not know - the preacher is not the only one that does not know about it. But you see, if we choose to point our lives in that place of darkness, we do so because we are trying to HIDE what we are. If we choose to walk in the light as He is in the light - in other words, walk so that the truth shines on our life and shows us what we really are - well, then we are not trying to hide anything. Notice what this scripture says: if we confess our sins, if we agree with God that we are sinful, we are not trying to hide anything.
It is like the Apostle Paul talked about the law being our schoolmaster, drawing us to Christ. If God’s word did not expose what I really was, then how would I ever become aware of my need for God? When I got sick with my cancer - if I never felt bad, if I never suffered, I would never have gone to the doctor and I would have died. So pain and suffering, we do not like it . . . humility, we do not like it . . . shame, we do not like it. But without some of these negative things we would never be aware that we were in need, and if we never understand that we are in need, we would never seek a Savior. I mentioned this morning about the mountaintops and the valleys - you sort of see what I am getting at. It is just impossible for us to always remain on those mountaintops, and the valleys are just as necessary, or even more so, than the mountaintops.
“Neither is there any creature that is not manifest in his sight: but all things are naked and opened unto the eyes of him with whom we have to do.” - Hebrews 4:13 (KJV)
Naked - that is, completely exposed - and opened unto the eyes of Him with whom we have to do.
A Shadow Needs Something in the Way
Now think about a shadow. In Him is no shadow, neither variableness or turning . . . in Him is no darkness at all, not even any dim places. A shadow is the result of something standing between an object and the light. And you will notice, just the way it is by nature, a shadow ALWAYS points AWAY from the light. A shadow never points toward the light. You see the significance of that in our lives? If we are walking in darkness, if we are looking for shadows to hide things, we are going in the complete opposite direction of the light.
And the sun never casts a shadow on itself. Well, “Preacher, that is kind of a duh.” But again, that is an example teaching us there is no darkness on the truth. In fact there are no DEGREES of truth . . . there is no such thing as a half-truth. If God is light, God is truth, and in God there is no darkness at all. That means there is no half-truth, and there is no “well, this is true under this circumstance, but under this circumstance over here the truth can change.” It does not work that way.
The Bible tells us there are three that bear record in heaven - the Father, the Son, and the Holy Ghost. Well, “in him is no darkness at all” teaches us that there is nothing in between God the Father, God the Son, and God the Holy Spirit. There is nothing that blocks the light of the Father from reaching Jesus Christ . . . nothing that blocks the light of Jesus from ever reaching the light of the Holy Spirit, and then all the way back around.
Now you remember there were some individuals in the churches in the days of John, there in Ephesus. These individuals were promoting the error that Jesus was not here physically - He only SEEMED to be. Their reasoning was that the physical part of the world had to be dirty, and there was no way anything physical could be clean and righteous. So Jesus, being God - being God in the flesh - could not have been here in the flesh, because the flesh is sinful. Well, these individuals claimed to walk with God. They claimed to be in the light . . . and while walking in the light of God, they also kept a hold of their darkness. They put their hands tight around the error they were promoting. And what John is simply saying is this: you can say what you want to, but darkness and light cannot exist in the same place. They cannot exist together.
GOING DEEPER · WHOSE WORDS WERE THESE?
Not preached on Sunday evening - extra study.
The false teachers in those churches taught that sin belonged to the body - to the low, physical world - and that the ones with the “higher knowledge,” or the saved soul, had gotten above all that. So “we have no sin” was not something John made up. That was their SLOGAN. And when John says “if we say . . . if we say . . . if we say,” he is quoting their own words back to them, one at a time, and holding every one of them up to the light.
Three Things People Say
Now there are three things people say in the verses we were looking at, verses five through ten. “If we say we have fellowship but . . .” and then they give an excuse. “If we say we have no sin” - that is a lie. And “if we say we have not sinned” - that is also a lie.
So notice first John one and six, the first one we look at.
“If we say that we have fellowship with him, and walk in darkness, we lie, and do not the truth:” - 1 John 1:6 (KJV)
What these individuals are doing is putting the label of Christianity on their lives and DIVORCING the label from the life. They are pretty much saying, “My being a Christian really does not have anything to do with my behavior or my manner of life.” Well - duh. Can you not see the inconsistency in that mentality? Now the walk they are talking about, to walk in darkness - once again, the purpose of this evening’s lesson is that God is not looking for perfection, He is looking for basically honesty. There is not a one of us who can honestly claim that we never walk in darkness, or places of less light, or places that are shadowy. What this is talking about is not sinless perfection . . . it is talking about the PATTERN of our life.
I have been walking for over sixty-eight years. There has been an occasion or two when I have stumbled, scraped my knee, fallen flat on my face. But the pattern of my life is that I am walking upright on my feet. That is the pattern of my life - my life is not defined by the few times I have stumbled. That is the idea here: the pattern of our life, not the fact that we stumble.
You ever go to the supermarket and stand there in front of the magazine rack and pick out a magazine and look at it? Well, how is that different from SUBSCRIBING to that magazine and getting it in the mail regularly, once a month or twice a month? There is a difference between a subscription and “I am just going to look at this magazine one time.” There is a difference between patterning our life after our pet sin - subscribing to whatever it is - and just a one-off. Folks, none of us are perfect. We have all been guilty of picking one off the rack and looking, just one time. Well, to walk in the light is to subscribe to RIGHTEOUSNESS.
So the pattern it is talking about is not just a bad day. It is not talking about the individual who stumbles and says, “Oh, man, I hate that I stumbled.” It is talking about when you WALK in darkness - the individual who has a paid subscription for the foreseeable future to whatever it is.
Then verse eight - the second lie.
“If we say that we have no sin, we deceive ourselves, and the truth is not in us.” - 1 John 1:8 (KJV)
Now the second lie fools the person who is telling the lie. The first lie is intended to fool OTHERS - to make me appear different from what I really am. With the second lie, I am actually deceiving my own self. It is like this: “Brother Kenneth, I have not subscribed to this magazine - I just borrowed yours.” And just because I borrowed it and did not really subscribe, that is not the same thing - that is different. You see the pattern? I am patterning my life after error, whether I borrow that error or whether I subscribe to it . . . but in my own mind I am deceiving myself, because I justify it. I have not officially bought into whatever sin it is that is leading me astray. A classic example of that - I remember a past president we had who got caught with his hand in the cookie jar, and he just redefined what sin was and made the problem go away - or at least tried to. That really does not work.
And the third lie - and this is really the worst one of all - verse ten.
“If we say that we have not sinned, we make him a liar, and his word is not in us.” - 1 John 1:10 (KJV)
Now notice what it says: we make Him a LIAR. Who do we make a liar? We contradict God. We can fool others, we can fool ourselves, and we can contradict God by subscribing to this way of life that is in error.
“For all have sinned, and come short of the glory of God;” - Romans 3:23 (KJV)
Romans three and twenty-three pretty much nips this in the bud. Every person who has ever been born could put their name right there - erase “all” and put their name there - and it would be one hundred percent valid. “For Fred has sinned and come short of the glory of God.” “For Bobby has sinned and come short of the glory of God.” You get what I am saying? To say otherwise is to tell God, “You were mistaken.”
I have got an example here that I thought was kind of cute - I was kind of proud of it myself. A pretend FENCE. Let’s just get a herd of cows and pretend that there is a fence around those cows. Do you think the cows will stay in that field? Well, I am going to live my life and just pretend that I am righteous. Do you think that is going to do any good? The only one I am deceiving is me. And the way to realize we are just pretending the fence is there . . . if we go out at midnight on a new moon and walk where we are pretending that fence is, well, we can convince ourselves that the fence is really there. But if we go out at noon in broad daylight and walk in that same place, the pretending will not work. God is light. And if we look at God’s word, we will see ourselves exposed as we really are - which may not be comfortable, but it is NECESSARY, because if we never see our sin, we will never seek a Savior from that sin.
So God is not asking for a perfect record . . . He is asking for an honest walk.
The Truth - Walk in the Light
“But if we walk in the light, as he is in the light, we have fellowship one with another, and the blood of Jesus Christ his Son cleanseth us from all sin.” - 1 John 1:7 (KJV)
First of all, if we walk in the light - if we pattern our life after God’s truth - we will have fellowship with one another, at home and in church. And the blood of Jesus will cleanse us from all sins. Now on the surface you may say, “Well, preacher, that sounds like after we get saved we have to do good stuff to maintain our salvation.” The idea here is that you have to understand this is talking to the FAMILY. Now you remember what the purpose of the letter of First John was. The gospel of John, I am going by memory here - “that ye may know that ye have eternal life.” And then First John - and I may have my Johns mixed up, forgive me if I do - is so that his joy in you may be full . . . so that your cup will be full and STAY full. Well, how does that cup stay full?
GOING DEEPER · THE MASK WE WEAR IN THE CHURCH DOOR
Not preached on Sunday evening - extra study.
Walking in the light gives us two things. The first is fellowship with one another - not just fellowship with God, but with each other, at home and in the church. And fellowship means partners who own something together. Well, nobody can be partners with a MASK.
Suppose I walk into the church with a smile on my face and anger in my heart. When we go into business with someone, when we put our name on the title next to our partner, we expect them to have skin in the game - just like we have something to lose. People, if I am unwilling to practice in my life - or at least TRY to practice - what I preach from the pulpit, how can our partnership in this church be genuine? And if we are wearing a mask of hypocrisy - and I am not talking about an occasional stumble, I am talking about a subscription to one of the three lies - then we are not in fellowship with God, and we are not in fellowship with each other, and we will not be until we CANCEL the subscription.
All right, I have always been kind of bad about this - I will dip my spoon into the soup and I have to concentrate really hard, because I have always had a little bit of a tremor, and if I am not careful I put as much food in my mouth as I possibly can. I am a horribly impolite eater. But I have got this spoon, and it is holding all the liquid I can possibly put on it. Well, if I start trembling, that liquid comes out of the soup. For our joy to remain full - if I take my eyes off of Jesus Christ . . . you remember what happened to Peter. He was sinking in the water until he did what? Until, “Lord, save me.” Jesus reached out, and when he saw the Master, he quit sinking. Well, when we take our eyes off of the truth, this cup of joy starts shaking, and what was a full cup, some of it starts splashing out.
Now I want to correct a possible misconception. The Bible is not telling us that if our joy ever gets full, it is going to stay full no matter what. It is telling us that we CAN have a full, complete joy. And if we walk in the light, that cup will remain full . . . it will not spill over, empty out, and we will not get the tremble. It remains topped off.
So if we walk in the light we will have fellowship one with another, each other, at home, and also His blood will cleanse us from all sins. The blood KEEPS ON cleansing. Now we are not talking about our salvation - this is addressed to the family, and it is talking about fellowship, not sonship. So if we walk in the light, the blood of Jesus constantly cleanses our life, so that if we are a Christian today and choose to walk in the light, the blood of Jesus Christ will give us the strength and the motive to be a Christian tomorrow. That kind of thing.
The Confession
Now one John one and nine. I want to say this is really important scripture - but what scripture is not important?
“If we confess our sins, he is faithful and just to forgive us our sins, and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness.” - 1 John 1:9 (KJV)
To confess does not mean to pull out a list and name everything we did wrong. The first thing wrong with that is that it is not possible - we cannot possibly know all the wrongs we do. We sin ignorantly. We sin in ways we do not even realize. To confess is to SAY THE SAME THING that God says about our sin. “Well, preacher, I just made a mistake.” It was not a mistake - it was a sin. “Well, preacher, you just do not know what I was going through. I was sort of justified in that.” I do not have to know what you were going through. No, you were not justified in that - God says it was a sin. “Well, preacher, I am not as bad as they are.” Well, you may not be, but that still does not excuse our sin. Confession is when we stop hanging a “but” on the end of an excuse.
The kids mess around in the kitchen, and they come in the living room with chocolate all over their face. “Mom” - or Sarah, or Granny - “have you been in the cookie jar?” Well, why would you ask a kid if they have been in the cookie jar when it is so obvious they have? It is to get the child to realize, “Well, maybe I should not have done that. I probably should have asked permission for that.” That is pretty much what David did. We are not going to go there and read it, but in the Fifty-first Psalm, David pretty much got caught with his hand in the cookie jar. We cannot get our hand out of the cookie jar until we ADMIT that it is in the cookie jar. We cannot remove our hand from where it should not be until we realize, “My hand should not be there.”
GOING DEEPER · DAVID JUST AGREED WITH GOD
Not preached on Sunday evening - extra study.
God already knows - and confession is us finally saying what God has known all along. That is exactly what David did. Psalm 51:3-4 - “For I acknowledge my transgressions: and my sin is ever before me. Against thee, thee only, have I sinned, and done this evil in thy sight: that thou mightest be justified when thou speakest, and be clear when thou judgest.” There is no excuse at all in David’s confession. David simply agreed with God that he had SINNED.
And it says that God is faithful and just, if we confess our sins. To be FAITHFUL means that you can count on God to keep His promise - if we agree with Him about our sin, He will forgive us. And to be JUST means that the price for that sin we committed has already been paid. First Peter two and twenty-four - there is a little comment I want to make.
“Who his own self bare our sins in his own body on the tree, that we, being dead to sins, should live unto righteousness: by whose stripes ye were healed.” - 1 Peter 2:24 (KJV)
It would not be right, it would not be proper, it would not be fair, it would not be according to the law for God to hold you and me accountable for sins that have already been paid for. He is faithful - He will keep His word and forgive - and He is just. He is not going to hold me accountable for a debt that He already paid on the cross.
GOING DEEPER · ALL UNRIGHTEOUSNESS - THROUGH THE WHOLE HOUSE
Not preached on Sunday evening - extra study.
And notice what God cleanses - “all unrighteousness.” God does not just cleanse the one sin we named in our confession. The named sin opens the door . . . and the cleansing goes all the way through the entire house, the complete life.
So not to confess our wrongs does not mean that we become lost. It means we are still saved. But what it is telling us is that we have stopped minding our Heavenly Father. And once again, first John one and nine is written to the FAMILY. If we confess our sins - who confesses? The family confesses - He is faithful and just to forgive us our sins and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness.
Now one John two and one:
“My little children, these things write I unto you, that ye sin not. And if any man sin, we have an advocate with the Father, Jesus Christ the righteous:” - 1 John 2:1 (KJV)
Oh, he is writing us this letter so that we can live perfectly sinless lives? No, he is writing it so that we can AVOID sin. If we do not avoid sin, we have an advocate - a go-between that will take our sins and argue on our behalf, so that we can escape judgment, because that sin has already been paid for. Now that does not mean we are going to avoid consequences, because we set things in motion - that is just the way life is.
GOING DEEPER · FELLOWSHIP KEPT OPEN
Not preached on Sunday evening - extra study.
A guard here, so no one misreads it. Verse nine is written to the family of God. Verse nine keeps FELLOWSHIP open . . . it does not buy back being His child. A child who sins is still a child - 1 John 2:1. And neither is verse nine a formula for the lost to say in order to get saved - or “re-saved.” The lost come to salvation by repentance toward God and faith in the Son, not by some act of naming their sins.
The Operating Room
I will leave you with this thought, and try to be honest. In terms of confession - “Well, I did this, but . . .” - is there a “but” hanging on the back end of our confessions? Now this is not a threat so that we have to be afraid we are going to become lost. It is an INVITATION to step into the light, to see what our problems actually are so that we can go to Jesus for forgiveness. What this is designed to do is to show us that our hand is in the cookie jar where it has no business. And once we admit that, once that is exposed to us by the light of God’s word - “Oh, my hand should not be there. Oh, thank You, God, for showing me. Forgive me” - that is what God is looking for.
I have asked the musicians to come forward as we prepare for an invitational hymn this evening . . . but one other example, talking about God is light. I suppose most everybody has either been in an operating room or knows a little bit about one. An operating room has lights that will just blind the fire out of you . . . just real bright. Well, why is that? So the doctor can see to cut out every little bit of what is wrong. We understand that you would not want a doctor operating on you in a dark operating room, would you? Well, why are so many so intent on living their lives in the dark? God’s word is the light, and the light is intended to expose what should not be there - not so that we can reach in and cut ourselves, but so that we can take that to God in prayer and ask Him for forgiveness, and ask Him to remove the cancer of sin - or however you want to phrase that.
GOING DEEPER · THE QUESTION TO TAKE HOME
Not preached on Sunday evening - extra study.
God already knows we do not have a perfect record - His Word says so: “For all have sinned.” God is not waiting for us to get everything right before He forgives us or before we start following Him. He is simply looking for somebody who will agree with Him. I am only going to ask one question tonight, and I do not want you to answer it out loud: is there anything we are still keeping in the dark . . . and not calling a sin?
Please consider what you heard this evening as we stand and sing.


